The Freedom You Say You Want Might Terrify You

The empty Saturday finally arrived, the one they had been longing for through weeks of overscheduled days. Nothing on the calendar. No obligations, no plans, no one needing anything. Total freedom, at last, a whole open day to do anything at all. And they spent it vaguely anxious, scrolling, restless, unable to settle, and went to bed that night with a strange dissatisfaction, having been handed exactly what they wanted and not known what to do with it.

We say we want freedom. We mean it, mostly. We long for the open day, the open road, the life with fewer constraints, and we chafe against the obligations and the structures and the walls that hem us in. And then, on the rare occasions we actually get it, the wide-open thing, we discover something uncomfortable about ourselves, which is that freedom, real freedom, the kind with no walls at all, is not the pure relief we imagined. It is also, quietly, terrifying.

You can see it in small ways constantly. The paralysis in front of a menu with too many options, when a short menu would have been a relief. The strange comfort of a deadline, which removes the freedom to keep deliberating and forces the thing to be done. The way people leave one rigid structure and quickly build another, because the open space where the structure was turned out to be harder to bear than the structure ever was. We ask for the walls to come down, and then we get busy, without noticing, putting up new ones, because a room with no walls is not a room. It is just exposure.

A Danish philosopher gave this feeling a name. He called it the dizziness of freedom, the vertigo that comes not from being trapped but from being truly free, from standing in front of genuinely open possibility and realizing that nothing is deciding for you, that it is all on you, that you could do anything and therefore must choose, and that the choice, and everything that follows from it, is entirely yours to answer for. That is not a comfortable feeling. That is the feeling of standing at the edge of a great height, and the dizziness is not fear of falling. It is the terror of knowing you could jump, that nothing is stopping you but you.

This is why the empty Saturday is so hard. The full day is easy, in a way, because the obligations decide. You do what has to be done, and the doing spares you the deeper question of what you actually want, what you would choose if nothing were chosen for you. Strip the obligations away and the question rushes in, unbearable and open, what do I actually want to do with this, with a day, with a life, and most of us flinch from it and reach for the phone, because the phone is a small wall, a way of filling the terrifying open space with something that decides for us.

The uncomfortable truth underneath is that we are not only prisoners longing for freedom. We are also, a little, wardens who prefer the cell, because the cell at least tells us where we stand. The walls we complain about are also the walls that hold us up, that spare us the vertigo, that answer the unbearable question of what to do by simply not permitting most of the options. Take the walls away and you are free, truly free, and you find out that freedom is not a hammock but a high open ledge, and that some part of you would rather have the railing back.

None of this means freedom is bad, or that we should stay in our cells and stop longing for the open day. It means that when the open day comes, we should not be surprised by the vertigo, or mistake it for a sign that something is wrong. The dizziness is not a malfunction. It is what freedom actually feels like, and the work is not to flee it back into busyness but to stand in it, tolerate the exposure, and do the frightening thing freedom requires, which is to choose, without anything choosing for you, and to own the choice.

The empty Saturday ended, unsatisfying, half-scrolled away. But there was something to learn in the discomfort of it, which was that the freedom they had longed for was real, and that they had flinched from it, and that the flinching, not the freedom, was the thing worth looking at.

The freedom you say you want is real. It is also a high open ledge, and part of you would rather have the railing. That is worth knowing before you get the day you asked for.

⁂

Perhaps while reading this you thought of an open day, or an open choice, that you longed for and then could not quite bear, filling the free space with something that would decide for you.

I wonder why the freedom we ask for so often terrifies us when it arrives, and whether part of us is not only a prisoner longing for open space but also a warden who prefers the cell, because the cell at least tells us where we stand.

You might, the next time real openness arrives and you feel the vertigo, recognize it for what it is, not a sign that something is wrong but the actual feeling of freedom. The work is not to flee it back into busyness, but to stand in it long enough to do the frightening thing it asks, which is to choose, with nothing choosing for you.